Essarr LoreBook

Trying to go against the current

User Tools

Site Tools


lb:gto

Great Teacher Onizuka

Onizuka Eikichi, ni-ju-ni-sai, a bachelor, has recently become a teacher at a well-renowned private school in Tokyo. Prior to his teaching career, he worked odd jobs and before even then, he was the infamous leader of a bōsōzoku (Japanese biker gang). While the idea of a gang leader becoming a teacher may be scary, you’ll find that once you get to know him, you’ll wish he were your teacher; and real.
Despite coming out in the 90s and early 2000s, the story of GTO is still just as Great today as it was then.
Alongside this article, there’s another dedicated to the Adaptations of GTO.

Reviews

GTO: Great Teacher Onizuka - Manga

The manga can be best described as a masterpiece. Of course, now that that’s out of the way, let’s get into specifics.
Onizuka Eikichi, ni-ju-ni-sai, is the centre of the manga… which is obvious, seeing as it’s named after him. Despite being the centre, he isn’t always the protagonist… sometimes he isn’t even at the centre of a particular story arc. However, his influence is felt… everywhere basically. His appearance in an area is enough to drive the plot and can even drive the decision-making of characters.
Most of the story focuses on solving the woes of the various students Onizuka comes into contact with, ending with them becoming his friend, usually. In-between the major arcs are a few smaller, “breather” arcs, which are typically just slice-of-life things. Occasionally, there’s also an arc revolving around a particular teacher in the school. I did notice, however, that later on a lot of the teachers stop being relevant to the story.
Speaking of the teachers… quite a few of the teacher characters come off as… less than noble people. This is obviously done intentionally, to show how hypocritical they are to criticize Onizuka, who, despite appearing like a punk, is a comparatively Great teacher, if a little too honest and laid-back.
The series also seems to criticize the Japanese education system, which is too concerned with test scores and appearances and not enough about the students themselves. I’m not sure if the critique can apply to other school systems, as I went through a largely apathetic system in comparison. Besides this, the series concerns itself with what a teacher should or should not be.
Now to move onto stuff I found… off.
I explain this in the speculah, but I have a feeling Kanzaki goes through the same character arc twice. This confused me and still confuses me, because I didn’t notice anything else like this happen. It’s a bit off, but doesn’t bother me too much… as I believe the arc it was a part of is one of the best in the whole series; it being the climax of the Principal‘s arc, a development in Miyabi‘s arc and has some of the highest tension in the whole series. It’s definitely one of my favourites, but Kanzaki‘s second character arc definitely degrades the quality.
Besides that, I have only one other issue that I care about: Mayu. I never really… got… what his point was? He always felt like a male version of Kanzaki, but not as smart. I assume he drops out of the story after his arc because Fujisawa-sensei didn’t know what to do with him.
I also feared I’d be disappointed by the inciting incident of Class 3-4’s terrorism; fearing it would either be too unrealistic, too contrived or too weak a reason. I was shocked and pleasantly surprised to find it was actually handled fairly well (something the adaptations seem to universally fail at). However, it took a bit of thinking before I concluded it was good.

I remembered a very specific thing that I dislike about Onizuka in particular: when things that are immoral are portrayed as good or neutral. The one example I can think of is when Fuyutsuki gives a few students some alcohol, which they then drink together with her. The surrounding context is that this is her attempt to get closer to the students in her own way, copying Onizuka in a way. I don’t think I specifically need to explain why this is a morally bad thing, but the manga doesn’t treat it as morally wrong.

GTO: Great Teacher Onizuka - Anime

The anime is a (mostly) faithful adaptation, I’d have to go through it again to see where it differed from the manga.
There are 3 main issues with it though.
The first is Tomoko and her character arc, which is changed. I suspect this is due to influence from the Drama. At the idol contest, Tomoko doesn’t do improv acting. Instead, she talks to Miyabi through a phone, about how she misses being her friend. I find this to degrade her character and it makes her resulting popularity feel contrived. As I saw the anime before the manga, I didn’t realise what a great girl Tomoko was until I went and read it.
The second is the Teshigawara related stuff, which only includes his first arc and not his second. This isn’t as bad as Tomoko, but it makes his story feel incomplete.
The third issue is the biggest. The ending.
The ending arc takes place over the course of the 3 last episodes. The arc is centred around the reason class 3-4 started their terrorism and focuses (a little) on Miyabi. It isn’t done as well as in the Manga… and the way it was written basically guaranteed no (easy) sequel series. The ending is also fairly obviously rushed.
Besides that, it’s a fine piece of work.

Great Teacher Onizuka 1998 - Drama

I’d say this adaptation changes a lot about GTO, but it still maintains the core of GTO. For a list of changes (I’ve noticed), please look at Adaptations of GTO.
The more risqué aspects of GTO have been toned down. I assume this was done because TV. I consider this a positive and a negative.
On the one hand, it isn’t full GTO, so viewers don’t get a feel for the full experience. On the other, I don’t have to hesitate about recommending it to my more innocent compatriots.
The show’s biggest disadvantage is the length. It is made up of 12 45ish minute episodes. Compare this to the anime, with 43 24 minute episodes. This essentially forced the writers to condense everything as much as possible (that, and they didn’t have as much to work with as the anime). However, the condensing is done… really well. The drama doesn’t suffer from the issues of the anime, because it essentially does its own thing. I assume some decision making went like this: “We only have the first half of Teshigawara’s arc and its clear Fujisawa-sensei plans to do more with him, but this is all we have and not much time. Let’s make some small changes here and there to make the arc complete.”
Unlike the anime, which is pretty faithful, but falters near the end… the drama feels like a complete product. I truly admire the writers here, they really knew what they were doing (most of the time).
There is, however, one rather big contrivance: the reason class 3-4 starts the class terrorism. It doesn’t work very well at all. The anime at least made sense, even if it wasn’t as good as the manga… this one doesn’t make any sense to me. It takes jumping through a few illogical hoops to get it to work. It was written clearly just to keep the story going.
Besides the writing, there are a few additional things I’d like to mention. The show is filmed like a soap opera… or at least that’s the feeling I get from it. The acting, camera work and music all contributes. The romantic tension between Onizuka and Fuyutsuki is toned way up… so much, I heard the actors got married. Bravo! Due to having to condense the storyline, characters tend to get relegated to the background once their arc ends. The fight scenes in this show are ridiculous, being in unnecessary slow-motion and with weird sound effects… later they just cut away instead.

GTO 2012 Drama

This one is a bit of a mixed bag. This one improves many of the aspects of the ‘98 version, like the fight scenes… and it isn’t shot like a soap opera anymore.
This one tries to be more faithful to the manga, avoiding merging characters together. It doesn’t work as well as it thinks however. The writing is built on a quite a few contrivances. I noticed one, in the first episode. Different from the ‘98 version, where I only noticed near the end. The Adaptations of GTO article goes into more detail.
Like the ‘98 version, it also fails to provide a good enough reason for class 3-4 to start the class terrorism. However, I didn’t finish reading the manga before watching this, so I didn’t realise it at the time… but they were trying to be more faithful. Explaining it here a bit: (and note this spoils the manga) In the manga, the class terrorism starts because Miyabi, in a childish fit of jealousy, claims her teacher (who she had feelings for) had raped her/had her raped. One of her classmates, Takumi, took this so seriously he bashed the teacher’s head in, getting expelled in the process. This essentially scared Miyabi into not revealing the truth. The rest of the class, being disgusted by the claim of rape, started the class terrorism. Miyabi then took the lead as a way of running from the truth. What happens in the drama: Mizuki Nanako was a member of class 3-4 who was responsible for collecting and keeping her class’ money for the cultural festival, ends up losing it, through the actions of a burglar. Her teacher accuses her of stealing it for herself and the rest of the class starts doubting her innocence too. This, apparently, is too much for her and she commits suicide in front of her classmates. Miyabi then finds a note from her, explaining she just wanted everyone to trust her. Miyabi, feeling guilty, rewrites it to make it say she wanted the teacher to trust her, kicking off the class terrorism. Miyabi’s part in kicking it off is kept faithful - that being her lying - but the rest of it feels contrived (and her reason for lying is also contrived). It seems like none of the adaptations can get this one quite right. In the original, it was a slightly malicious prank that went out of hand really quick, but here it feels… bad. This isn’t even the only example of this kind of thing happening in the show.
Besides that, a few characters aren’t done well either. I’d say the students are (mostly) fine, but the teachers are completely shafted, with the plot barely focusing on any of them, besides Fuyutsuki. The ‘98 version kept a balance between the teachers and students, with some episodes being about specific teachers. Uchiyamada-sensei is especially done dirty, with him basically having nothing besides a few jokes at his expense. This also leads to contrivances! Since there’s no reason why Uchiyamada and the rest of the teachers would side with Onizuka at the end. This is so bad in fact, that I’m tempted to call it a plot hole.
The show is also shorter than the ‘98 version (admittedly by only one episode) leading to, shockingly, more contrivances. Unlike the ‘98 version, which only had about 6 volumes worth of material, the 2012 version had 20 and the spin-off 「GTO Shonan 14Days」. The writers then tried to fit as much as possible into those 11 45 minute episodes… but it didn’t work… leading to contrivances.
I should end off with a few things I like. Onizuka is still done well (enough) and, unlike the ‘98 version, he actually looks like Onizuka. Saejima is different from his manga counterpart, but since I find him hilarious, I don’t really mind. A lot of the jokes are quite good and they had me laughing… I still giggle to myself when I think of them.
I have yet to watch the specials, the Taiwan specials and the second season. I couldn’t even finish the second season’s first episode, because it was so bad.

GTO Paradise Lost

Something I should note at the start. The series is still being published and I’ve only read up to Volume 16… however, I don’t think I will keep up with it or ever finish reading it.
Now for what I thought on it: I didn’t like it, although this wasn’t obvious to me at first. Overall, I was disappointed while reading, but I needed to do some thinking before I actually concluded it was bad. It’s a serious downgrade from GTO and I feel it ends up degrading the whole series.
First I’ll mention some stuff I liked or found interesting:

  • Onizuka being in prison, with him relaying his experiences to other prisoners.
  • The concept of a class of celebrities.
  • Uchiyamada‘s small arc.

Of those, the last one is the highlight of the series. It’s one of the few redeeming features of it. I won’t write much about it, because I don’t want to spoil it.
That is everything I liked, let’s move on.
The series is a giant continuity error. This is because GTO took place in the late 90s, early 2000s, while Paradise Lost takes place around the mid-to-late 2010s. However, Paradise Lost supposedly only takes place three years after the end of GTO. I don’t think I have to explain how this is a problem. The two end up feeling disconnected as a result. It’s interesting that this isn’t acknowledged at all in-universe, which seems to be an attempt to shrug it off. It not being acknowledged or explained only makes it feel more disconnected.
That’s one of the bigger issues, but the biggest issue in this series lies with the characters: None of them feel distinct.
Class G just feels like a watered-down Class 2-4. This watered-down nature is best exemplified in their class terrorism, which lasts only a few chapters and never reaches the heights of Class 2-4… despite the fact the series makes a big deal out of the terrorism at the start. And, unlike Class 2-4, their presence is barely felt in the series. Characters continually disappear and reappear at random, which is justified as them being celebrities, but then we can’t get to know them properly. When they do appear, they just feel like the one time appearance students from GTO… no distinct personality or appearance. The ones who do appear more often just feel like re-hashes of Class 2-4 characters in personality and appearance. So interesting idea number 2 has failed to connect.
These character issues don’t just apply to Class G, but to most of the other characters as well. Interestingly though, two decent characters show up later, who end up becoming teachers at the school. Unfortunately, they aren’t enough to salvage the series.
Onizuka in prison isn’t even handled all that well either. At first, he tells his tales to other prisoners, but eventually he stops telling them… and the series seems to forget this is how it chose to tell the story. While the shifting from prison to flashback was alright before, once Onizuka stops telling the tales, it starts to feel disconnected.
Finally, I only have a few smaller things to say:

  • “Showbiz” being portrayed as the Yakuza is kind of stupid. I have a hard time taking it seriously.
  • I think the cult(s) are stupid. Although this might be due to the rest of the series being bad.

I believe now it’s obvious why I don’t intend to finish the series. It should have ended with Shonan 14 Days.

Spin-offs

GTO Shonan 14 Days

While it’s called a sequel, I believe it’s more accurate to call it a side-story, seeing as it takes place during GTO.
I didn’t notice any particular issues, I believe I only noticed one potential continuity error; if memory serves right, however, it was an extremely minor one.
There isn’t much to say here, it’s a very Onizuka story.
At worst, I believe Ayame to have been too similar to Fuyutsuki.

Inokashira Gargoyle

Also known as 「Ino-head Gargoyle」.
This spin-off focuses on Saejima (the titular “Gargoyle”) and his 3 adventures. The series essentially sees him transition from a weak crooked cop into a fairly decent cop, with him trying his best to become a good man at the end.
However, it ends rather abruptly, which makes me think Fujisawa-sensei had more planned but was forced to end it soon. There’s essentially a two-chapter ending arc, that leaves at least 3 plot threads unresolved (one of them being a result of this arc heh).
Unfortunately, the lack of a good resolution means it has a rather… depressing after-feel.

GT-R: Great Transporter Ryuji

I haven’t had the time to read it yet.

Characters & Worldbuilding

Teachers

Onizuka Eikichi

The titular character of the series, the Great Teacher himself.
Prior to GTO, he was one of the main characters of 「Shonan Junai-gumi」 where he formed and led a biker gang. At the start of GTO, he is no longer in a biker gang and he works odd jobs, not really knowing what he wants to do with his life. After an encounter with a hot highschool girl (and learning she was in a relationship with her teacher), he decides to become a teacher. After becoming a teacher though, he finds he actually loves the job, living up to his (self-appointed) nickname.
His personality can be best described as simple. He thinks very highly of himself (for those who couldn’t tell from Great Teacher Onizuka), but he keeps it within reasonable boundaries… so he’s more confident than egotistical. Onizuka doesn’t tend to think things through and lets his own feelings get the better of him (except when he realises he needs to be calm), this can lead to both hilarious and horrifying results. As a result, he gets angered easily, very basic seduction techniques always get him and his greed… well yeah. He also occasionally dresses up, just for fun, seemingly. His body is also that of a god as he can do the impossible and survive the impossible (he fell off the roof of the school, landing on a car and came out with light bruises), leading other characters to describe him as a cockroach.
However, one aspect of his character is as clear as day: his undying loyalty to his students. Onizuka would die if it meant helping his students. This likely stems from his undying loyalty to those he considers his friends (he essentially views his students as his friends and treats them as such). This probably makes him one of the greatest teachers ever.
His teaching style isn’t based around raising student test scores (he doesn’t even understand the subject he’s meant to teach), but about making them into decent human beings, true to their own principles. He frequently clashes with the rest of the teaching staff over his extremely unorthodox teaching style (which occasionally looks to threaten the lives of his own students). What makes him such a great teacher is how he treats the students as equals… they insult him, he insults them back. The students don’t see him as a teacher, they see him as a trusted friend.
And, truly, is that not beautiful?

Fuyutsuki Azusa

Fuyutsuki is a teacher at the same school as Onizuka, having gone to the same job interview as him. Unlike him though, she wasn’t rejected at first.
After she hears Onizuka’s first speech in the series (about teachers calling their students trash), she becomes a great admirer of Onizuka, which eventually leads to her developing romantic (and sexual yukyuk) feelings for him. She is also very attractive, which leads to her female students bullying her out of jealousy.
She has a very nice personality, being somewhat innocent too, occasionally being disgusted by Onizuka’s pervertedness. She also makes an effort to be respectful and friendly (unlike Onizuka), which also contributes to her being bullied. later on, she does loosen up a bit, after taking Onizuka’s advice to treat the students as people.
Despite her enthusiasm for teaching, she struggled with why she wanted to teach in the first place, not really understanding why she was attracted to the idea of being a teacher. Over time, however, she finds a reason for being a teacher, partially with Onizuka’s help.
Due to her friendliness with Onizuka, she ends up taking his side most of the time, which also gets her on good terms with the class 3-4 students (at least those on Onizuka’s side).

Saejima Toshiyuki

Saejima was the leader of his own biker gang back in the day, they called him the「Mad dog of Kamukura」; now, he’s a cop… a transition few understand.
Despite being a cop, he is not unwilling to commit crimes, having several side-business’ that frequently dip into the illegal. Despite this, he is a good man at heart and his own spin-off shows him become better. He deeply regrets many of his past actions.
He is, like Ryuji, also quite loyal to Onizuka… willing to do all manner of things to help him out… although he does frequently try to double-cross or trick Onizuka. However, he does help out Onizuka when he realises he really needs help. When Teshigawara starts rampaging, he helps Onizuka get to him and he’s even willing to kill Teshigawara if Onizuka told him to, saying he’s willing to cover it up. While not the most legally-conscious, he is still ultimately loyal to his friends.

Uchiyamada Hiroshi

Uchiyamada is the vice-principal (or principal) of the school Onizuka teaches at. From day one, he hated Onizuka and his hatred for him only seems to grow. This is partially justified, as Onizuka caught him groping Fuyutsuki on the bus and beat him for it; then, Onizuka performed a german suplex on him, for calling expelled students trash. Onizuka also frequently seems to (inadvertently) destroy his precious Toyota Cresta. His hatred for Onizuka gradually grows more and more unhinged. Eventually though, he does let go of his hatred, realising he was no longer the enthusiastic teacher he was in the past. Onizuka still gets on his nerves, but he doesn’t call him a bad teacher anymore.
He was, for a while, obsessed with the reputation of the school, willing to fire teachers and expel students if it meant saving the schools image.
At home, he feels like his family takes him for granted, not treating him with much respect (despite the fact he’s the one keeping them afloat). His obsession with the Cresta is born from the idea he can fix all his family ideas by going on a hot springs trip with it, although later it seems to be based on the fact it keeps getting destroyed (If I got it right, he goes through 7 Crestas over the course of the series).

Students

Kanzaki Urumi

With an IQ of 200, Kanzaki is the most intelligent character in the series. Unlike many of her classmates in 3-4, her class terrorism started in elementary school.
Despite, or due to, her intelligence… she like playing around doing whatever she finds fun. This stems from her belief that life is ultimately meaningless, thus she spends her time having fun.
She initially starts her class terrorism after she develops a (very) close bond with her teacher, Fujimori-sensei. Fujimori-sensei started out by teaching her extra material, but Kanzaki inevitably outpaces her. Fujimori grew more and more frustrated over time, leading to a burst of anger… that leads Kanzaki to start her class terrorism. Her bond with Fujimori-sensei is essentially that of a daughter and mother, which made Fujimori’s outburst all the more painful.
Onizuka’s presence essentially changes her outlook on life, no longer suicidal or nihilistic (well…). This also leads her to (eventually) fall in love with Onizuka. She also reconnects with her old teacher, with both of them apologising for each-others mistakes.
Her personality is playful overall. She views herself as better than others due to her intelligence, although she tones this down over time. When something happens she doesn’t like (Onizuka in trouble, her secret coming out) she tends to get incredibly serious, which occasionally leads her to do some… less than legal things.

Kikuchi Yoshito

Kikuchi is a very smart guy, although not as smart as Kanzaki. He frequently gets the highest test scores in school.
He’s also very tech-savvy, owning a computer and knowing how to photoshop (very impressive back then). Hacking is also something he’s kind-of good at.
While his class terrorism motivation is the same as most of his classmates, he’s ultimately more of a maverick than others. He gives up the class terrorism upon realising Onizuka isn’t like most teachers.

Aizawa Miyabi

Miyabi is essentially the leader of the class terrorism operation. She allows herself to be consumed by the terrorism, essentially letting her hatred of teachers control her. This leads her to feel betrayed by the others when they gradually take Onizuka’s side. She ends up distancing herself from her classmates, becoming a loner, dyeing her hair and dressing like a “slut.” She’s also not happy with the situation in her home, where she feels like her parents are pretending to like each-other, when they really seem to hate each-other, leading her further down the path of slut.
She comes off as a bitch for most of the series and it isn’t until the end when her bitchy personality is explained.

Nomura Tomoko

Tomoko is a slow-witted girl, earning her the nickname Toroko (Slo-mo-ko in some English translations), she makes up for her slow wit with her huge breasts. She’s also fairly clumsy, messing up things that people normally wouldn’t mess up. Her introduction features her messing up a plan by Miyabi to seduce Onizuka, which gets her expelled from Miyabi’s group.
Tomoko, Miyabi and Urumi are all childhood friends, having attended the same elementary school.
After being isolated from Miyabi’s friend group, Onizuka befriends her… and enters her in an idol contest. Due to her improv talents, she doesn’t win the contest, but finds herself getting picked up by an agency. She, like other girls, develops love for Onizuka as well.
It’s clear from… everything… that Tomoko will eventually be a very famous and successful idol.

Murai Kunio

One of the leaders of the class terrorism, he’s turned to Onizuka’s side fairly quickly. He’s somewhat rebellious, which is evident from his dyed hair and general disregard for authority. After joining Onizuka’s side, he starts goofing around with him.
Murai’s mother is very young, having him at the age of 13. His father abandoned them both early on and his mom was forced to take care of him herself. He respects her very much and has a distrust towards men (as a result of papa going poof). Others joke this respect borders on a mother-complex.
Their relationship is, from my view, kind of like between an older sister and younger brother, but with motherly undertones too.
As she’s very attractive, Murai fears his mom might attract the wrong kind of guys (like Onizuka).
While he comes off and presents himself as a bit of a punk, he’s ultimately a very sweet boy.

Speculah & Analysis

Spoilers will be unmarked here, so wander at your own risk.

Kanzaki Urumi goes through the same arc twice

I first experienced the second arc in the 2012 show and then later in the manga. I was a little surprised it came from the manga, because I thought it was a bit of a downgrade from her first one.
Well whatever, I thought, let’s see how it was in the original.
It was then that I felt like something was off. To me, it felt like Kanzaki-chan’s character went back to how she was at the start of her first arc, then she went along the same progression.
This actually kind of irks me, because I don’t think the second arc is as good and it’s like Fujimori-sensei (a far more sympathetic character than Kanzaki’s mother) is forgotten about. It’s like she disappears.
To be fair, Fujimori-sensei seems to disappear before this arc. But I always felt it was implied she and Kanzaki reconnected and always assumed they got back together. And although this is pure speculah, I even believed Kanzaki-chan moved to her house.
I even thought the manga would make it so that Fujimori-sensei officially adopts Kanzaki. This was what I expected to happen at the end of Kanzaki’s second arc too. Although that might just be me getting ahead of myself.
That being said, when considering the arc it’s a part of (i.e., ignoring Kanzaki-chan), I’d say it’s one of the heights of the series. I just wished her two arcs were merged in some way instead.

lb/gto.txt · Last modified: 2024-04-25 21:25:09 by ninjasr

Donate Powered by PHP Valid HTML5 Valid CSS Driven by DokuWiki